Posted by
Chelsea E. Dyer on Monday, November 09, 2009 1:48:48 PM
I am a rock, I am an island, I am a Christian,
Conservative Feminist. That’s right I said it, a Christian,
Conservative Feminist. I am a woman who realizes that it hasn’t been
long since women have been able to vote. I am a woman who realizes that I still don’t make the same amount of money as my male counterpart. I
am a woman who realizes that I have the right to be a full time mother
even if liberal feminists mock me for doing so. I am a woman that
realizes that being a mother is a full time job and that if I choose to
become a mother it is my duty to be the best one I can be, and that
cannot be done part time. I am a woman that realizes that if I so
choose I can work in the professional world and that I have the same
right to be there as a man. I am a woman who believes that I am more
than what I look like, that I do not have to sexualize myself to get
where I want to go. That said, I’ve been very disappointed that
Conservatives have chosen to champion former Miss California Carrie
Prejean. Regnery Publishing, a Conservative book publisher, is even
publishing a book by her called “Still Standing”.
Back in April when the story came out that a Miss
USA contestant was asked about her opinion on gay marriage to which she
voiced her belief that marriage is between a man and a woman I was
surprised and even thought, “good for her.” When I heard the names
Perez Hilton had called her I was disgusted and, well, not surprised. Unlike
Ms. Prejean, who says that “being a 22-year-old college student not
really into politics, or I wasn’t at the time. But now I have a new
outlook. I am disgusted at the way some people can be so intolerant,” I
am a 21 year old college student who follows politics closely and has
been to bat time and time again in my personal life for my beliefs. I am not at all surprised by the backlash. I would never have assumed something like Miss USA or pageantry in general to be something that a Conservative would champion. Apparently I was wrong.
I as a conservative woman, applaud Ms. Prejean for stating her beliefs. I do not applaud her for objectifying herself and being rewarded for how she looks. Conservatives,
and Conservative Christians especially, that hold her up as a
representative for family values are actually doing a disservice to the
Conservative movement. I cannot be the only Conservative,
Christian female that sees the hypocrisy in Ms. Prejeans’ answer and
subsequent championing by the Conservative movement. The following is the actual question and answer that took place at the 2009 Miss USA pageant.
Perez Hilton: “Vermont recently became the fourth
state to legalize same-sex marriage. Do you think every state should
follow suit? Why or why not?”
Carrie Prejean: “Well I think it’s great that
Americans are able to choose one way or the other. We live in a land
where you can choose same-sex marriage or opposite marriage. You know
what, in my country, in my family, I think I believe that marriage
should be between a man and a woman, no offense to anybody out there.
But that’s how I was raised and I believe that it should be between a
man and a woman.”
First of all, the answer Ms. Prejean gave was not a very eloquent one. Her opinion in fact was not necessary to the question. Even
if she wanted to make it known that same-sex marriage is wrong, which I
applaud, she could have also been diplomatic that it is an issue that
each state should have the right to decide. She is after
all called as Miss USA to be a representative right? Second, Ms.
Prejean is competing in a pageant that requires her to walk on stage in
a bikini that in no way can be called modest. I don’t think anyone would think that this would be a very Christian thing to do, call me old fashioned. If I say that though, I get labeled a hypocrite, a prude, etc. I
make no claims to be perfect, but I think it’s problematic that Ms.
Prejean is touting family values whilst competing in a pageant that
overtly sexualizes the contestants. I think it’s also
hypocritical when she has modeling photos taken that are overtly sexual
yet claims, not that they were wrong, but that, “I am a Christian, and I am a model. Models pose for pictures, including lingerie and swimwear photos.” I don’t know about other women, but I don’t believe that lingerie modeling is targeted to us.
Conservative Christians should have taken issue
with the fact that Perez Hilton, a judge at the event, called Prejean a
“dumb b****” on Youtube.com following the event and subsequently on an
appearance on Larry King said the following, “Yes. I do expect Miss USA
to be politically correct.” If Ms. Prejean had lost because of the poor
way she gave her answer, or because she wasn’t as diplomatic as she
should have been, fine, but it is clear that at least according to one
judge, had she said she believed in same-sex marriage, she would have
won. Granted, Miss USA is a private organization and has
every right to not want a Conservative to represent them, we all know
that if a Conservative organization did the same thing there would be
uproar.
Nowhere in this equation do Conservatives need to hold her up as the poster woman for family values.
Nowhere
in this equation do Conservatives need to reward her for being part of
a pageant, and modeling career, that is anathema to the things she says
she stands for. The issue should have been that this is another case of Liberal intolerance towards Conservatives.
Parading Ms. Prejean around not only makes
conservatives look like hypocrites it reinforces the stereotype of the
chauvinistic Conservative male. Here’s an excerpt from the book, “Still
Standing,”
“I knew immediately that I would lose the
competition because of my answer…. I didn’t want to offend anyone but
it was more important to me to be biblically correct than politically
correct.”
It sounds to me that while she was biblically
correct that homosexuality, and it would follow, homosexual unions, are
wrong, she missed the part in the Bible about modesty. I do not mean
that antagonistically, however, I do feel that the hypocrisy is
astounding.
In the months that followed I’ve watched the Conservative movement champion Ms. Prejean. I
watched Liberty University offer her a scholarship and Clare Booth Luce
policy institute honor her as a “Great Conservative Woman.” I’ve since
sent emails to both organizations displaying my frustration, with no
response. The release of her book today is the tip of the iceberg. I cannot be the only Conservative Christian woman that feels like an island. If I mention my frustration with the hypocrisy I’m deemed a Pharisee. If
I mention that Ms. Prejeans’ chosen path as a model and pageant queen
is less than morally sound I’m put aside by Conservatives, of which I
am one, as a feminist (as if Conservative women cannot be femists as I
have shown clearly at the beginning of this piece as false), as bitter,
as jealous. Not as someone who believes that women should respect
themselves and not take the easy way out by objectifying themselves and
participating in activities that the world deems okay.
Ms. Prejean is allowed to have one foot in the world, and one foot in championing Christianity. The
only way that she should be even remotely allowed to champion family
values is if she were to come out and say that her previous actions as
a model and pageant winner were in fact immoral. I myself have done things I’m not proud of, but I do not try and defend them as if they are okay.
In my 21 years on this earth I have had to defend my beliefs. Since I became legally able to vote I made it a part of my life to understand, follow and participate in politics. While I have not been on a national stage being applauded for my genetics, I have written, campaigned and debated my beliefs. I
recognize full that our culture champions women’s rights and at the
same time calls women objectifying themselves sexually as their “right”
and as “liberating.” I wouldn’t expect Conservatives to buy into this
and I’m painfully disappointed that Christians do. Prominent
female Conservative Ann Coulter even skirted the issue in her article,
“Liberal Taliban Issues Fatwa Against Miss California.” Coulter wrote
the following, “Liberals believe abortion is a sacrament, but smoking,
wearing short skirts and modeling lingerie are mortal sins.” While she
makes a valid point, she too misses the hypocrisy. Not the
hypocrisy claimed by the liberals that Christians aren’t allowed to
make mistakes, but that Christians shouldn’t call the sin they commit
okay, but another sin wrong. That is in fact hypocrisy. Coulter also
wrote this, “Christians aren’t people who believe they are without sin;
they’re people who know they’re sinners and are awestruck by God’s
grace in sending his only Son to take the punishment they deserve.”
Christians also have to acknowledge their sins and ask for forgiveness,
not claim that it’s no big deal.
If I’m the only Conservative woman who feels alienated, fine, but I sincerely believe that I’m not alone. I am a Christian Conservative woman, and Carrie Prejean, you do not represent me.